Skip to Content

Giving Tuesday, Gift Memberships and Holiday Crowds: What’s Actually Working?

The holidays can bring donations, memberships and visitors… but which campaigns are actually driving them? Learn how to reach the right audiences, measure what works, and start the new year with better insights.
November 18, 2026 by
Giving Tuesday, Gift Memberships and Holiday Crowds: What’s Actually Working?
Datafy, Keri Hanson

The final weeks of the year are a busy time for museums, zoos, aquariums and other attractions. Between gift memberships, seasonal events and year-end fundraising campaigns, there's a lot happening and a lot of revenue on the line. Giving Tuesday alone generated an estimated $4 billion in donations in 2025, up 13% from the previous year. And according to the Blackbaud Institute, December accounts for nearly one-fifth of annual charitable giving. That's a lot of opportunity packed into just a few weeks. 

But with donations, memberships and ticket sales coming in all at once, how do you know which of your marketing efforts are working to drive them? And how can you use those insights to make next year’s campaigns better?


Here are four ways to make the most of your year-end marketing: 


1. Give Every Campaign a Clear Goal 

One family sees your holiday ad, donates on Giving Tuesday, buys a gift membership, and attends your holiday light event. Amazing! But it’s also three different transactions that might be tracked by three different teams. Before your campaigns launch, establish separate goals for donations, new memberships, gift memberships, renewals and ticket sales. Then compare results against the same period last year to understand what’s growing, and where there’s room for improvement. 

Don’t wait until January to figure out what success looks like. Decide what you want to report to your stakeholders now so that you’re collecting the right information from the start. 


2. Make Sure You’re Reaching the Right People 

Not every audience should get the same holiday message. Someone who’s donated for years might not be a great Giving Tuesday prospect, while a family that recently visited but hasn’t purchased a membership could be the perfect audience for a holiday membership offer.  

Use what you know about your audience to build more relevant campaigns. Think: past donors, lapsed members, recent visitors, families within driving distance, and people who regularly visit attractions. Then give each campaign a clear message and call to action. Rather than asking someone to donate, become a member and buy tickets all at once, focus on the offer that’s most relevant to them. You’ll make it easier for people to take action and easier for your team to understand what’s working. 


3. Think Beyond the Gift Memberships 

Gift memberships are a great way to bring new people into your attraction, but the opportunity doesn’t end when someone makes the purchase. Think about it: The person buying the membership might already know and love your attraction. The person receiving it might have never visited before - it’s an entirely new relationship that you have the opportunity to build. 

Make sure gift recipients receive a warm welcome, an invitation to visit and reasons to keep coming back. Then pay attention to what happens next. Do they visit? How often? Do they renew the following year? Those insights can help you turn a one-time gift into a long-term relationship. 


4. Measure What Actually Happened, Not Just Who Clicked 

Email opens, ad impressions and clicks can tell you whether people engaged with your marketing. But they don't tell you whether someone actually bought a membership, made a donation or showed up at your attraction. That's where connecting your marketing to real results becomes so valuable. By linking advertising performance with your own membership and ticketing data, you can understand which campaigns drove purchases and revenue, rather than relying on clicks alone.

You can also look at who's visiting. Are your new members primarily local families? Are holiday events attracting visitors from neighboring communities? Are you reaching new audiences or bringing back familiar faces? These are the kinds of insights that help you make smarter decisions about where to invest your marketing dollars next year.


Make This Year’s Results Work for Next Year 

When January rolls around, you want to have more to show than a successful fundraising total or a busy holiday season. You want to know what worked, who responded and where your biggest opportunities are.

And those insights shouldn't sit in a year-end report. Put them to work! If gift memberships aren't renewing, rethink your onboarding experience. If a particular audience is driving more ticket sales, consider how to reach more people like them. And if your holiday events are attracting new visitors, find ways to bring them back throughout the year. Because the goal isn't just to finish the year strong. It's to use what you learned to make the next one even better.


Want to make your visitor data work harder all year long? Read our blog on using data to help attractions thrive in every season.

Tags